Soaring Cost of Breast Cancer Care Troubles Patients

D.C. resident Kimberly Curtis said the cost of breast cancer from diagnosis through treatment can quickly erode a patient's life savings. /Courtesy photo
D.C. resident Kimberly Curtis said the cost of breast cancer from diagnosis through treatment can quickly erode a patient's life savings. /Courtesy photo

Kimberly Curtis has battled and overcome breast cancer.

In doing so and despite having what she said is excellent health insurance, the northeast D.C. resident has also had to reach deep into her pocketbook to pay for the costs associated with the illness.

Curtis, a registered nurse, said co-pays for doctor visits and examinations and the percentage she lays out for medicine and the change in diet that most survivors experience can leave most breast cancer patients broke.

“I am a grateful survivor. I am very grateful for the services I received at MedStar Georgetown University Hospital,” she said. “[However], a couple of things that are very concerning include the frequent visits, meal plan changes and the financial expenses that I’ve incurred after I was diagnosed.”

After her initial testing three years ago which was followed by surgery and other planned treatments, Curtis — like most cancer patients — had to schedule visits with several oncologists including surgical, radiation and chemotherapy and medical.

Such visits often occur every three months during the first year and, if treatments prove to be going well, the patient can then visit oncology doctors once every six months.

“However, if one decides to be on medication treatment, that person must see the medical oncologist every three months for five years,” Curtis said.

It’s also suggested that patients consult with a nutritionist.

“I decided to eat healthier to lose weight and to do all that I could to not have the cancer come back,” she said. “With these frequent followup visits comes a very expensive medical bill. I am blessed to have insurance and yet there are still bills that are constantly coming in. To be honest, I am not even sure if all my original bills are fully paid. It’s saddening at times.”

Insurance companies, patients and government health plans are reportedly paying $1 billion annually just for routine tests to confirm diagnoses and billions more for treatment.

Dr. Sharon Giordano at the MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston said patients often get stuck with thousands of dollars in bills that can take years to pay off.

Giordano and a team of doctors recently went through insurance claims filed by more than 14,000 breast cancer patients between 2008 and 2012 and found expenses across a single class of drugs varied by as much as $46,000.

“There were big variations in the cost of treatments we could prescribe,” Giordano told NBC News.

Even more surprising: Some of the more effective and least toxic treatments were, in fact, cheaper.

“There is one chemotherapy regimen called TAC,” Giordano said.

That’s short for Taxotere plus adriamycin plus cyclophosphamide — three different chemotherapy drugs that hit the cancer in different ways.

“It was both one of the highest cost and one of the highest toxicity regimens,” she said.

Swapping a related drug called paclitaxel for Taxotere cut both the side effects and the costs, Giordano said.

“It’s almost $15,000 cheaper,” she said. “I think most people would think those pretty equivalent in terms of efficacy.”

However, NBC News noted that this wasn’t easy to find out.

“For me, working at a hospital, I don’t really see that at all. I don’t have an easy way to access what the costs would be,” Giordano said.

Even treatments that should be cheap varied widely in cost.

“We give a pill called an aromatase inhibitor that blocks estrogen after chemotherapy. There are three different ones that are all approved and they are probably equivalent,” Giordano said.

Those pills reduce the chance that tumors will come back in the other breast.

“Depending on what insurance plan [a patient has] one would be costlier and one would be less costly,” Giordano said. “Doctors should try to find out. The problem is, it is time-consuming.”

And how much a patient ended up paying herself varied wildly depending on which insurance plan she had.

“I was somewhat surprised at the relatively high costs patients were bearing — around $3,000 out of pocket on average,” Giordano said. “What I think was more concerning was that top quarter, top 10 percent of patients are getting really hefty bills costing them $10,000 or more.”

Not surprisingly, people with so-called catastrophic health insurance plans, which charge low premiums but which also don’t reimburse for much, paid the most out of pocket.

Expenditures for cancer care have grown from $72 billion in 2004 to $125 billion in 2010 and are estimated to reach $158 billion by 2020, Giordano’s team wrote.

“The costs of cancer care are increasing at an unsustainable rate — two to three times faster than other health care costs,” Giordano said. “Patients’ out-of-pocket costs have also been rapidly increasing.”

Roxanne Martinez, a six-year survivor, received a dual blow when she was diagnosed in 2010.

Pregnant at the time of her diagnosis, Martinez was terminated from her airport job because of the times she was forced to call in sick, she said.

“That left me in a huge bind, having to pay COBRA insurance premiums of about $600 to $700 per month, on top of co-pays, deductibles and other costs,” Martinez said. “I ended up cashing out my entire savings and retirement accounts — about $30,000 — to help fund my cancer treatment and health premiums.”

A large network of friends, family and others rallied behind Martinez and helped her raise an additional $20,000 to help pay for medical and living expenses, she said.

“After I exhausted my COBRA benefits, I was uninsured for several months due to having a preexisting condition, of course that was before Obamacare,” Martinez said. “I had to navigate the health care system without insurance and negotiate a cash payment with my surgeon for a reconstruction surgery.”

Martinez ultimately filed for bankruptcy.

“I am now in remission and happy to be alive,” she said. “Breast cancer may have taken my breasts, my hair, my job, my retirement and savings, but it will never take my faith or hope.”


About Stacy Brown 439 Articles
I’ve worked for the Daily News of Los Angeles, the L.A. Times, Gannet and the Times-Tribune and have contributed to the Pocono Record, the New York Post and the New York Times. Television news opportunities have included: NBC, MSNBC, Scarborough Country, the Abrams Report, Today, Good Morning America, NBC Nightly News, Imus in the Morning and Anderson Cooper 360. Radio programs like the Wendy Williams Experience, Tom Joyner Morning Show and the Howard Stern Show have also provided me the chance to share my views.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.